In a physical medicine and rehabilitation (PM&R) or pain practice, many patients present with complaints of “stiffness” or “clumsiness.” While these can be symptoms of common MSK conditions like osteoarthritis or rotator cuff pathology, they are also the hallmark signs of Cervical Spondylotic Myelopathy (CSM). For the board-certified physician, mastering the UMN physical exam is the only way to prevent a missed diagnosis of spinal cord compression.

1. The Pathophysiology of the UMN Sign

An Upper Motor Neuron (UMN) lesion occurs when there is compression or damage to the spinal cord (myelopathy) or the brain. This results in a loss of the “inhibitory” signals from the brain to the spinal cord, leading to:

• Hyperreflexia: Exaggerated deep tendon reflexes.
• Spasticity: A velocity-dependent increase in muscle tone.
• Pathological Reflexes: The emergence of primitive reflexes that are normally suppressed in healthy adults.

2. Hoffman’s Reflex: The “Babinski of the Upper Extremity”

Hoffman’s reflex is a classic board topic used to screen for cervical spinal cord compression (usually above the C5/C6 level).

• The Maneuver: The clinician stabilizes the patient’s middle finger at the distal interphalangeal (DIP) joint and “flicks” the nail of the middle finger downward.
• Positive Response: A positive Hoffman’s sign is the involuntary flexion/adduction of the thumb and/or the index finger.
• Clinical Significance: While a symmetric Hoffman’s can sometimes be found in “hyper-reflexic” healthy individuals, an asymmetric or very brisk Hoffman’s in the setting of neck pain is highly suggestive of cervical myelopathy.

3. Other High-Yield UMN Signs

• Babinski Sign: Stroking the lateral sole of the foot. A positive sign is the upgoing great toe and fanning of the other toes (signifying corticospinal tract involvement).
• Clonus: A series of involuntary, rhythmic muscular contractions and relaxations. It is tested by performing a rapid, sustained dorsiflexion of the ankle. More than 3 beats of clonus is considered pathological.
• Inverted Radial Reflex: When the brachioradialis reflex is tapped (C6), but the response is actually finger flexion (C8) rather than elbow flexion. This suggests a lesion at the C5/C6 level that is compressing the cord and simultaneously causing a Lower Motor Neuron (LMN) lesion at that specific root level.

4. The “Great Mimic”: Cervical Spondylotic Myelopathy (CSM)

CSM is the most common cause of spinal cord dysfunction in adults over age 50. It often masquerades as simple MSK issues:

• Mimic 1: Carpal Tunnel Syndrome: Patients with CSM often report “numb, clumsy hands” and difficulty with fine motor tasks (buttoning shirts, handwriting). If a CTS patient has a positive Hoffman’s, you must image the neck.
• Mimic 2: Lumbar Stenosis: “Myelopathic gait” can look like the heavy, tired legs of lumbar stenosis. However, CSM will have hyperreflexia, while lumbar stenosis (a LMN issue) will have diminished or absent reflexes.

5. Clinical Decision Making: The Nurick Scale

The Nurick Scale is often used to grade the severity of myelopathy based on gait, which helps determine the urgency of surgical intervention:

• Grade 0: Signs of cord compression but no gait abnormality.
• Grade 5: Bedridden or wheelchair-bound.

6. Safety and “Red Flags”

Identifying a UMN sign changes the entire treatment plan:

• Contraindication: Spinal manipulation (chiropractic or manual therapy) is strictly contraindicated in patients with suspected myelopathy, as it can lead to acute cord injury.
• Pre-Surgical Focus: While surgery (decompression/fusion) is the primary treatment for CSM, PM&R focuses on balance training and fall prevention to protect the patient until they can be stabilized surgically.
• Diagnostic Gold Standard: MRI of the Cervical Spine. Look for “T2 signal change” (myelomalacia) within the cord, which indicates permanent or semi-permanent cord damage.

---

7. High-Yield Board “Fast Facts”

• Hoffman’s Sign: Thumb and index finger flexion; suggests UMN lesion above C5-C6.
• Inverted Radial Reflex: Tap C6, get C8 (finger flexion); pathognomonic for CSM.
• Clonus: >3 beats is pathological.
• LMN vs. UMN: Radiculopathy is LMN (weakness, low reflexes); Myelopathy is UMN (stiffness, high reflexes).
• Clumsy Hands: A classic historical “red flag” for cervical myelopathy.